E-Start sprag blow ups research.
7 years 6 months ago #1003
by dynodave
Dave Comeau
atlanticgreen.com/contact.htm
E-Start sprag blow ups research. was created by dynodave
Over the years I have had a few starters come back to me totally blown up from a flipped sprag locking the drive train and causing the starter to rev "to the moon", followed by a destroyed starter.
The final effect is known well enough. The thing I have been researching is what is the failure modes that causes it.
I recently got back a second blow up from the same guy.
Digging a bit harder with him I came up with a few tidbits by examining the associate starter drive parts that I asked him to send up to me.
I will be looking to see if some of the same thing have caused failures in others and what are the contributing factors,
I will be looking into the brands of sprag makers besides the 16 or 18 dog bones/rockers.
These one way clutches are, after all, a standard industrial one way clutch and there are enough sources and price points for these parts to make a worth while survey,
It is curious to note that andover norton is supposidly making modified starter drivetrain components at considerable expense. Their sprag is approaching $180 yet a alibaba chinese one can be had for around $20.Some guys are using the chinese ones successfully so far.
The final effect is known well enough. The thing I have been researching is what is the failure modes that causes it.
I recently got back a second blow up from the same guy.
Digging a bit harder with him I came up with a few tidbits by examining the associate starter drive parts that I asked him to send up to me.
I will be looking to see if some of the same thing have caused failures in others and what are the contributing factors,
I will be looking into the brands of sprag makers besides the 16 or 18 dog bones/rockers.
These one way clutches are, after all, a standard industrial one way clutch and there are enough sources and price points for these parts to make a worth while survey,
It is curious to note that andover norton is supposidly making modified starter drivetrain components at considerable expense. Their sprag is approaching $180 yet a alibaba chinese one can be had for around $20.Some guys are using the chinese ones successfully so far.
Dave Comeau
atlanticgreen.com/contact.htm
The following user(s) said Thank You: commando6868
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- commando6868
-
- Offline
- Premium Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 113
- Thank you received: 45
7 years 6 months ago #1005
by commando6868
"THE FUTURE'S UNCERTAIN AND THE END IS ALWAYS NEAR"
Replied by commando6868 on topic E-Start sprag blow ups research.
A number of years back I was prepping my commando for an extended trip up to Maine around Mount Desert Island. I didn’t like the position of the clutch engagement so I was adjusting the clutch. I had the bike fully loaded and I took a ride down to the gas station to tank up. Everything was working normal. At the time I had a four brush starter in the bike that had been working for a few years. My 1975 had the original sprag from the factory, as far as I know. The bike had 5000 miles on it when I got it. I adjusted the clutch one more time hit the starter button and I could tell something drastic happened inside the primary, I kind of figured out what it was. I was lucky it happened in my shop and not on the road, needless to say I took another motorcycle on that trip. The sprag
was working normal until it didn’t, there was no sign that anything was wrong before it disintegrated.
was working normal until it didn’t, there was no sign that anything was wrong before it disintegrated.
"THE FUTURE'S UNCERTAIN AND THE END IS ALWAYS NEAR"
Please Log in to join the conversation.
7 years 6 months ago #1008
by dynodave
Dave Comeau
atlanticgreen.com/contact.htm
Replied by dynodave on topic E-Start sprag blow ups research.
Anybody out there?
Who uses OEM stock bronze clutch plates and who uses solid fiber clutch or barnetts?
I can tell you a story....
Who uses OEM stock bronze clutch plates and who uses solid fiber clutch or barnetts?
I can tell you a story....
Dave Comeau
atlanticgreen.com/contact.htm
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- commando6868
-
- Offline
- Premium Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 113
- Thank you received: 45
7 years 6 months ago #1009
by commando6868
"THE FUTURE'S UNCERTAIN AND THE END IS ALWAYS NEAR"
Replied by commando6868 on topic E-Start sprag blow ups research.
Fiber
"THE FUTURE'S UNCERTAIN AND THE END IS ALWAYS NEAR"
Please Log in to join the conversation.
7 years 6 months ago #1010
by PMellin
Pmellin
'73 750 Interstate
Replied by PMellin on topic E-Start sprag blow ups research.
Barnett fiber
Pmellin
'73 750 Interstate
Please Log in to join the conversation.
7 years 5 months ago - 7 years 5 months ago #1011
by dynodave
Dave Comeau
atlanticgreen.com/contact.htm
Replied by dynodave on topic E-Start sprag blow ups research.
Didn't realize you had a MKIII E-start? The whole point of my research is to find out the reasons and failure modes for the sprag mechanism.Non original clutch material being considered as contamination.PMellin wrote: Barnett fiber
Dave Comeau
atlanticgreen.com/contact.htm
Last edit: 7 years 5 months ago by dynodave.
The following user(s) said Thank You: PMellin
Please Log in to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.051 seconds
Copyright © 2026 NNENO.org - Produced by Media Guys dot com